fbpx

Should You Be Allowed to Fix Ball Marks Anywhere on the Course, Not Just the Green?

📌 The Unfair Ball Mark Dilemma

You hit a perfect approach shot, but instead of landing cleanly, your ball:

🚨 Buries into a deep pitch mark in the fairway.

🚨 Settles into a rough, uneven divot-like dent.

🚨 Gets caught in an old, unrepaired mark left by another golfer.

You’re not allowed to repair the ground before hitting your shot—unless you’re on the green.

🚨 Should that rule change? Should golfers be allowed to fix ball marks anywhere on the course?

Let’s break it down:

What the rules actually say

Why some golfers think the rule is unfair

Would changing the rule be good for the game?

⛳ What Do the Rules Say About Fixing Ball Marks?

Under Rule 8.1a of the Rules of Golf (USGA), golfers CANNOT repair pitch marks, divots, or damage on:

🚫 The fairway

🚫 The rough

🚫 Bunkers or penalty areas

The ONLY place you can repair a ball mark is on the green.

🚨 Translation: If your ball lands in a deep, unfair pitch mark in the fairway, you have to play it as it lies.

You CAN take relief if your ball is in an embedded lie (stuck in its own pitch mark), but ONLY if local rules allow it.

🤯 Why Some Golfers Think This Rule is Unfair

1️⃣ Why Can You Fix a Ball Mark on the Green But Not the Fairway?

• The rule says damage affects putts but doesn’t matter for full shots.

• But if your ball is sitting in a deep dent in the fairway, isn’t that just as unfair?

• Some golfers argue you should be able to repair any course damage caused by play.

🚨 Key Question: If the goal is a fair test of skill, why force players to hit from damaged turf?

2️⃣ It Punishes Good Shots More Than Bad Ones

• If you hit a great approach shot, you might end up in your own deep pitch mark.

• If you miss the green completely, your ball might end up in a perfect lie.

Should good ball-striking really be punished this way?

🚨 Key Question: Should golfers be penalized for hitting high, soft shots that land hard?

3️⃣ It Slows Down Play Because Some Golfers Try to “Fix” Their Lies Anyway

• Let’s be honest—some golfers already fluff up the grass or smooth the ground anyway.

• Allowing repairs could remove gray areas and prevent sneaky rule-breaking.

🚨 Key Question: Would changing the rule actually speed up play by eliminating complaints?

🔥 Why the Rule Makes Sense & Should Stay the Same

1️⃣ Golf Is Meant to Be a Test of Skill—Including Bad Breaks

• Golf isn’t just about hitting the ball well—it’s about handling adversity.

• Getting a bad break is part of the game—just like getting a lucky bounce.

• If every golfer could fix every imperfection, would the game lose some of its challenge?

🚨 Counterpoint: Is hitting from a damaged area really a “test of skill” or just bad luck?

2️⃣ It Would Be Hard to Enforce & Might Slow Down Play

• If golfers could repair ball marks anywhere, where do you draw the line?

• Would players start smoothing out lies before EVERY shot?

• Could this lead to more cheating or unnecessary rule debates?

🚨 Counterpoint: Could a simple limit (e.g., repair only pitch marks, not divots) prevent abuse?

3️⃣ It Keeps Course Conditions Consistent for Everyone

• If one group repairs ball marks but another doesn’t, is that fair?

• In tournament play, conditions should remain as natural as possible.

• The rule ensures everyone plays the course as they find it.

🚨 Counterpoint: Should weekend golfers have a different rule than professionals?

🔬 Should This Rule Be Changed? Possible Solutions

Option 1: Allow Ball Mark Repair Anywhere, But Only for Your Own Pitch Mark

• If your ball creates a visible pitch mark in the fairway or rough, you can repair it.

Prevents unfair lies but doesn’t let players fix every imperfection.

🚨 Problem: How do you determine what counts as “your own” ball mark?

Option 2: Allow Repairing Only in the Fairway (Not the Rough)

• If you hit the short grass, you should get a fair, playable lie.

• But in the rough, bad lies are expected—no repairs allowed there.

🚨 Problem: Would this lead to endless fairway repairs, slowing down play?

Option 3: Keep the Rule as It Is But Enforce Better Course Maintenance

• Instead of changing the rule, courses could do a better job of maintaining fairways.

• Encourage golfers to repair divots and ball marks properly.

• This could reduce the need for a rule change.

🚨 Problem: Many courses don’t have the staff or resources to fix every pitch mark.

📢 What’s Your Take?

Should golfers be allowed to fix ball marks anywhere on the course, or is the rule fine as is?

👉 Follow us on Facebook for more golf rules debates, insights, and discussions!

The Golf Bandit
The Golf Bandit

Hi, I'm Jan. I'm passionate about golf and have been playing for years. I love testing out new clubs and equipment, and I share my reviews right here on my blog. With access to the latest gear, I provide honest insights on how they perform on the course. I also enjoy sharing tips and tricks to help you improve your game. Thanks for visiting—hope you find something useful!

Articles: 249

Newsletter Updates

Enter your email address below and subscribe to our newsletter