📌 The Unfair Ball Mark Dilemma
You hit a perfect approach shot, but instead of landing cleanly, your ball:
🚨 Buries into a deep pitch mark in the fairway.
🚨 Settles into a rough, uneven divot-like dent.
🚨 Gets caught in an old, unrepaired mark left by another golfer.
You’re not allowed to repair the ground before hitting your shot—unless you’re on the green.
🚨 Should that rule change? Should golfers be allowed to fix ball marks anywhere on the course?
Let’s break it down:
✔ What the rules actually say
✔ Why some golfers think the rule is unfair
✔ Would changing the rule be good for the game?
⛳ What Do the Rules Say About Fixing Ball Marks?
Under Rule 8.1a of the Rules of Golf (USGA), golfers CANNOT repair pitch marks, divots, or damage on:
🚫 The fairway
🚫 The rough
🚫 Bunkers or penalty areas
✅ The ONLY place you can repair a ball mark is on the green.
🚨 Translation: If your ball lands in a deep, unfair pitch mark in the fairway, you have to play it as it lies.
✅ You CAN take relief if your ball is in an embedded lie (stuck in its own pitch mark), but ONLY if local rules allow it.
🤯 Why Some Golfers Think This Rule is Unfair
1️⃣ Why Can You Fix a Ball Mark on the Green But Not the Fairway?
• The rule says damage affects putts but doesn’t matter for full shots.
• But if your ball is sitting in a deep dent in the fairway, isn’t that just as unfair?
• Some golfers argue you should be able to repair any course damage caused by play.
🚨 Key Question: If the goal is a fair test of skill, why force players to hit from damaged turf?
2️⃣ It Punishes Good Shots More Than Bad Ones
• If you hit a great approach shot, you might end up in your own deep pitch mark.
• If you miss the green completely, your ball might end up in a perfect lie.
• Should good ball-striking really be punished this way?
🚨 Key Question: Should golfers be penalized for hitting high, soft shots that land hard?
3️⃣ It Slows Down Play Because Some Golfers Try to “Fix” Their Lies Anyway
• Let’s be honest—some golfers already fluff up the grass or smooth the ground anyway.
• Allowing repairs could remove gray areas and prevent sneaky rule-breaking.
🚨 Key Question: Would changing the rule actually speed up play by eliminating complaints?
🔥 Why the Rule Makes Sense & Should Stay the Same
1️⃣ Golf Is Meant to Be a Test of Skill—Including Bad Breaks
• Golf isn’t just about hitting the ball well—it’s about handling adversity.
• Getting a bad break is part of the game—just like getting a lucky bounce.
• If every golfer could fix every imperfection, would the game lose some of its challenge?
🚨 Counterpoint: Is hitting from a damaged area really a “test of skill” or just bad luck?
2️⃣ It Would Be Hard to Enforce & Might Slow Down Play
• If golfers could repair ball marks anywhere, where do you draw the line?
• Would players start smoothing out lies before EVERY shot?
• Could this lead to more cheating or unnecessary rule debates?
🚨 Counterpoint: Could a simple limit (e.g., repair only pitch marks, not divots) prevent abuse?
3️⃣ It Keeps Course Conditions Consistent for Everyone
• If one group repairs ball marks but another doesn’t, is that fair?
• In tournament play, conditions should remain as natural as possible.
• The rule ensures everyone plays the course as they find it.
🚨 Counterpoint: Should weekend golfers have a different rule than professionals?
🔬 Should This Rule Be Changed? Possible Solutions
Option 1: Allow Ball Mark Repair Anywhere, But Only for Your Own Pitch Mark
• If your ball creates a visible pitch mark in the fairway or rough, you can repair it.
• Prevents unfair lies but doesn’t let players fix every imperfection.
🚨 Problem: How do you determine what counts as “your own” ball mark?
Option 2: Allow Repairing Only in the Fairway (Not the Rough)
• If you hit the short grass, you should get a fair, playable lie.
• But in the rough, bad lies are expected—no repairs allowed there.
🚨 Problem: Would this lead to endless fairway repairs, slowing down play?
Option 3: Keep the Rule as It Is But Enforce Better Course Maintenance
• Instead of changing the rule, courses could do a better job of maintaining fairways.
• Encourage golfers to repair divots and ball marks properly.
• This could reduce the need for a rule change.
🚨 Problem: Many courses don’t have the staff or resources to fix every pitch mark.
📢 What’s Your Take?
Should golfers be allowed to fix ball marks anywhere on the course, or is the rule fine as is?
👉 Follow us on Facebook for more golf rules debates, insights, and discussions!