fbpx

Should Mulligans Be Allowed in Casual Rounds?

📌 The Great Mulligan Debate

We’ve all been there—you step up to the first tee, take a swing, and… shank it into the trees.

Your playing partner laughs and says, “Go ahead, take a mulligan.”

But is that fair game or just an excuse for bad shots?

🚨 Should golfers be allowed to take mulligans in casual rounds, or does that ruin the integrity of the game?

Let’s break it down.

⛳ What Exactly Is a Mulligan?

A mulligan is a do-over shot—a chance to replay a bad shot without penalty.

📌 Unofficial rule: Mulligans are not recognized by the USGA or R&A.

📌 Reality: Weekend golfers use them all the time.

🚨 Key Question: Should casual golfers be able to take one free shot per round—or is that just cheating?

🔥 Why Mulligans Should Be Allowed in Casual Rounds

1️⃣ Golf Is Hard—Mulligans Keep It Fun

• Not everyone is playing serious competition.

• Mulligans help casual golfers relax and enjoy the game.

• If you’re not playing for money or a handicap, who cares?

🚨 Reality Check: Some golfers don’t play often—shouldn’t they get a second chance?

2️⃣ They Speed Up Play

• If you shank a drive OB, hitting a mulligan is faster than taking stroke-and-distance penalties.

• Many golfers already don’t follow every rule—why waste time?

• Courses don’t always have marshals enforcing rules anyway.

🚨 Key Question: If mulligans keep the game moving, is that really a bad thing?

3️⃣ It Helps Beginners & High Handicappers Stay Interested

New golfers struggle—a first-tee mulligan can set a positive tone.

• If you’re playing for fun, why should you be punished for one bad swing?

No one enjoys losing five balls in the first three holes.

🚨 Reality Check: Without mulligans, would more casual players quit golf?

⛳ Why Mulligans Should NOT Be Allowed

1️⃣ Golf Is About Integrity—You Should Play It Properly

• If you take a mulligan, you’re not really keeping score.

• Golf is about dealing with bad shots, not erasing them.

• Mulligans create bad habits—if you rely on do-overs, you’ll never improve.

🚨 Key Question: Is golf meant to be a pure test of skill, even in casual play?

2️⃣ It’s Not Fair If Only Some Golfers Take Them

• What if one player takes a mulligan and another doesn’t?

• If you’re playing for a friendly bet, should mulligans count?

Where do you draw the line? One mulligan per round? Per hole? Unlimited?

🚨 Reality Check: If mulligans aren’t officially part of golf, why should anyone use them?

3️⃣ Mulligans Can Actually Slow the Game Down

• Some golfers take multiple mulligans per round.

• If you let one person re-hit every bad shot, rounds drag on forever.

• What about second putts? Should “gimme mulligans” count too?

🚨 Key Question: If the goal is pace of play, do mulligans actually help or hurt?

🔬 Possible Solutions: The Middle Ground

Option 1: One Mulligan Per Round, First Tee Only

You get ONE do-over—on the first tee.

No second chances on putts or approach shots.

Keeps casual rounds fun without getting out of control.

🚨 Problem: Some golfers will still take extra mulligans anyway.

Option 2: Mulligans Allowed, But They Must Be “Paid For”

• If you take a mulligan, you must donate $1 to a charity jar.

• Mulligans can only be used once per 9 holes.

• Adds a fun element but keeps it fair.

🚨 Problem: Not every group will agree on the rule.

Option 3: Only Allowed in Non-Competitive Rounds

• If you’re playing for money, bets, or an official score, no mulligans.

• If you’re playing for fun, do whatever makes the round enjoyable.

🚨 Problem: What if one player wants a mulligan, but others don’t?

📢 What’s Your Take?

Should golfers be allowed to take mulligans in casual rounds, or does that ruin the game?

Let’s hear your thoughts! 👇

👉 Follow us on Facebook for more golf debates, insights, and discussions!

The Golf Bandit
The Golf Bandit

Hi, I'm Jan. I'm passionate about golf and have been playing for years. I love testing out new clubs and equipment, and I share my reviews right here on my blog. With access to the latest gear, I provide honest insights on how they perform on the course. I also enjoy sharing tips and tricks to help you improve your game. Thanks for visiting—hope you find something useful!

Articles: 249

Newsletter Updates

Enter your email address below and subscribe to our newsletter