📌 The Nightmare Bunker Lie
You step into a bunker, and instead of a clean, smooth surface, you see:
🚨 A deep footprint right behind your ball.
🚨 A trench left by someone’s failed escape attempt.
🚨 Unraked, compacted sand that might as well be concrete.
You haven’t even swung yet, and your hole is already ruined.
But here’s the big question: Should golfers be allowed to repair bunkers before hitting a shot?
Let’s break it down:
✔ What the rules say
✔ Why bunkers are so inconsistent
✔ Should the rule be changed—or is it part of the challenge?
⛳ What Do the Rules Say About Repairing Bunkers?
Under Rule 12.2b of the Rules of Golf (USGA), golfers CANNOT repair the bunker before hitting their shot.
What You CAN Do:
✅ Remove loose impediments (rocks, leaves, etc.)
✅ Take relief for an unplayable lie (with a penalty stroke)
✅ Rake the bunker AFTER you hit your shot
What You CANNOT Do:
🚨 Smooth out footprints or unraked sand before playing
🚨 Test the sand’s texture with practice swings
🚨 Improve the area around the ball in any way
🚨 Translation: If you find yourself in a footprint, you’re stuck with it—play it as it lies or take a penalty.
🤯 Why This Rule Drives Golfers Crazy
Bunkers are supposed to be a hazard, but many golfers argue that the current rule is unfair.
Here’s why:
1️⃣ It’s Not Your Fault, So Why Are You Punished?
• If bunkers were always properly raked, this wouldn’t be an issue.
• But on busy courses, most bunkers are a disaster by the afternoon.
• So if the group ahead of you doesn’t rake, you’re playing out of their mess.
🚨 Key Question: Should you be penalized because someone else didn’t rake?
2️⃣ Bunkers Are Wildly Inconsistent
• Some courses have soft, fluffy sand—others feel like a construction site.
• Some bunkers are raked daily, others haven’t seen a rake in weeks.
• Some courses have deep bunkers, some have almost none.
🚨 The Problem: You never know what kind of lie you’re going to get—even from a perfect shot.
3️⃣ The Rules Already Allow Some “Improvements”
• You can repair pitch marks on the green.
• You can remove obstructions and debris anywhere on the course.
• So why can’t you fix a footprint in a bunker?
🚨 Key Question: If the goal of golf is a fair test of skill, shouldn’t you at least get a clean lie?
🔥 Should This Rule Be Changed? Here Are the Arguments
⛔ Argument AGAINST Changing the Rule (Keep It as Is)
✅ Bunkers are meant to be hazards—they shouldn’t be “perfect.”
✅ Bad luck is part of golf—you don’t always get a good lie.
✅ If golfers could rake before hitting, it would slow down play.
🚨 Counterpoint: If bunkers are hazards, why do we rake them at all?
✅ Argument FOR Allowing Repairs Before a Shot
🚨 Some golfers argue:
✔ Golf should be a test of skill, not random bad luck.
✔ If pros play on perfectly raked bunkers, why shouldn’t amateurs get a fair chance?
✔ This change would speed up play by reducing complaints and penalty drops.
✅ Example: The USGA already allows preferred lies in certain conditions—why not allow a quick bunker repair?
🔬 What Would a Rule Change Look Like?
If the rule were to change, here are some possible solutions:
Option 1: Allow Players to Smooth the Sand—But Only in a Small Area
• Golfers could rake the sand directly behind their ball but not the entire bunker.
• This would prevent players from creating a perfect lie while still eliminating unfair footprints.
🚨 Problem: Would this be too difficult to enforce?
Option 2: Allow Smoothing in Public Course Bunkers, But Not in Tournament Play
• This would help casual golfers on busy courses where bunkers are often in bad condition.
• Competitive golf would still require playing it as it lies.
🚨 Problem: This would create two different sets of rules for different levels of play.
Option 3: Keep It as Is, But Require Courses to Maintain Bunkers Better
• Instead of changing the rule, the focus could be on improving course maintenance.
• More rakes placed around bunkers and course staff smoothing bunkers more often.
🚨 Problem: Not every course has the resources to maintain perfect bunkers.
📢 What’s Your Take?
Should golfers be allowed to repair bunkers before hitting, or is the rule fine as is?
Let’s hear your thoughts! 👇
👉 Follow us on Facebook for more golf rules debates, insights, and discussions!