fbpx

Should Golfers Be Allowed to Place Instead of Drop When Taking a Penalty?

📌 The Drop Rule Dilemma

You hit a shot into a penalty area, or you take an unplayable lie, and now you have to take a drop.

You follow the Rules of Golf—drop from knee height, let it bounce, and watch in horror as:

🚨 It rolls into a divot.

🚨 It settles into thick rough.

🚨 It stops in a terrible lie that’s somehow worse than where you started.

At this point, you’re wondering… why can’t we just place the ball instead of dropping it?

Let’s break it down:

What the rules actually say

Why golfers hate the drop rule

Should the rule be changed?

⛳ What Do the Rules Say About Taking a Drop?

Under Rule 14.3 of the Rules of Golf (USGA), a player must drop from knee height when taking relief.

• The ball must land in the relief area and stay there.

• If it rolls outside the area, you must drop again (if it happens twice, then you can place it).

• The ball must not be placed unless a second drop fails to stay in the relief area.

🚨 Key Issue: Even though you’re taking relief, you might still end up in a terrible lie.

🤯 Why Golfers Hate the Drop Rule

Golf is supposed to be about skill, not luck—but the drop rule can feel completely random.

1️⃣ Sometimes Your Drop Makes Things Worse

✔ You take relief from casual water—only to end up in thick rough.

✔ You take a penalty drop from a hazard—only for your ball to settle in a divot.

🚨 Translation: You’re already being penalized for a bad shot… should the rules really add insult to injury?

2️⃣ It Adds Unnecessary Luck to the Game

Golf is supposed to be a test of skill—but the drop rule can turn it into a game of chance.

• The ball could land perfectly in the fairway or nestle into a horrible lie—all based on luck.

• It’s even worse when dropping on slopes, bunkers, or rough.

🚨 Key Question: If you’re already taking a penalty stroke, shouldn’t you at least get a fair lie?

🔥 Should This Rule Be Changed? Here Are the Arguments

⛔ Argument AGAINST Allowing Placement Instead of Drops

Golf is about playing the course as it lies.

Randomness is part of the game—good and bad luck happen.

Placing instead of dropping could make relief too easy.

🚨 Counterpoint: But isn’t the goal of a drop to provide relief? Why does a penalty stroke need to come with an extra punishment?

✅ Argument FOR Allowing Placement Instead of Drops

🚨 Some golfers argue:

If you’re already taking a penalty, you should at least get a fair lie.

Random bad drops can unfairly ruin a round.

The current rule adds unnecessary frustration and slows down play.

Example: The USGA already allows preferred lies in some conditions—why not extend that to penalty drops?

🔬 What Would a Rule Change Look Like?

If the rule were to change, here are some possible solutions:

Option 1: Allow Placement Instead of Drops (But Only in Certain Situations)

• Players could place the ball instead of dropping, but only:

✔ In penalty relief areas.

✔ When taking relief from abnormal course conditions.

✔ When dropping on slopes or bunkers.

🚨 Problem: Would this give an unfair advantage in certain situations?

Option 2: Let Players Choose Between a Drop or Placement

• Golfers could opt to place the ball, but only at the cost of an extra penalty stroke (e.g., an additional half-stroke in match play).

• This keeps the risk vs. reward balance while preventing bad luck from ruining rounds.

🚨 Problem: Some golfers might argue this is too complicated.

Option 3: Keep It as Is, But Add More Drop Zones on Courses

• Instead of changing the rule, more courses could introduce drop zones for common penalty areas.

• This would speed up play and reduce the number of unfair, bad-luck drops.

🚨 Problem: This relies on individual courses, not a rule change.

📢 What’s Your Take?

Should golfers be allowed to place instead of drop, or is the rule fine as is?

Let’s hear your thoughts! 👇

👉 Follow us on Facebook for more golf rules debates, insights, and discussions!

The Golf Bandit
The Golf Bandit

Hi, I'm Jan. I'm passionate about golf and have been playing for years. I love testing out new clubs and equipment, and I share my reviews right here on my blog. With access to the latest gear, I provide honest insights on how they perform on the course. I also enjoy sharing tips and tricks to help you improve your game. Thanks for visiting—hope you find something useful!

Articles: 249

Newsletter Updates

Enter your email address below and subscribe to our newsletter